Reviews: Heretic (2024) Movie Review
- Play Trailer Now! (Report missing/broken?)
- Related: [ Movie Details for Heretic ]
Subgenres: Religion, A24
Where does Heretic (2024) stand among horror films? Our review examines the scares, pacing, and what makes it unique in the genre.
Heretic (2024) is a psychological horror film that uses religion not as a source of supernatural possession but as a framework for manipulation, power, and control. Directed by Scott Beck and Bryan Woods, this A24 horror thriller follows two young Mormon missionaries who knock on the wrong door, only to find themselves trapped in a terrifying intellectual and psychological game orchestrated by a sinister yet fascinating host.
Heretic (2024) – A Psychological Horror That Unravels Faith and Control
Led by a career-defining performance from Hugh Grant, Heretic is an intense, dialogue-driven thriller that explores the dangers of ideological control, the fine line between belief and deception, and the illusion of choice. The film slowly unravels, keeping viewers in constant suspense, challenging both the characters and the audience with its layered, philosophical horror.
Director and Main Cast
Heretic is directed by Scott Beck and Bryan Woods, the creative duo behind A Quiet Place. Known for their ability to build tension through minimalist storytelling and claustrophobic environments, they bring that same precision to Heretic, where conversations become weapons and faith is both a shield and a trap.
Main Cast:
- Hugh Grant as Mr. Reed – A charming yet menacing man who draws the missionaries into his web of twisted religious philosophy.
- Sophie Thatcher as Sister Barnes – The more skeptical and analytical of the two missionaries, she fights to maintain control in an increasingly manipulative environment.
- Chloe East as Sister Paxton – More naïve and deeply rooted in her faith, her belief system makes her the easier target for Mr. Reed’s mind games.
Hugh Grant transforms completely for this role, delivering a dark, complex, and unsettling performance that showcases his ability to manipulate both his on-screen captives and the audience.
Plot, Themes, and Character Development
The film begins with Sisters Paxton and Barnes, two young Mormon missionaries, knocking on doors to share their faith. When they arrive at Mr. Reed’s house just as a storm rolls in, he welcomes them inside. At first, everything seems normal—he’s polite, intelligent, and curious about their beliefs. But the atmosphere shifts as his questions become unsettling, subtly twisting their faith against them.
A Psychological Labyrinth Disguised as Theology
Rather than relying on jump scares or supernatural horror, Heretic builds its terror through intellectual cat-and-mouse dynamics. Mr. Reed doesn’t just challenge their beliefs—he methodically dismantles them, piece by piece, until the missionaries are left questioning their own reality.
The true horror of Heretic is ideological entrapment—the realization that every choice is an illusion. As Mr. Reed presents his own "one true religion," the girls discover that no matter what path they take, the outcome remains the same.
Control, Manipulation, and the Fear of the Unknown
- Religious Symbolism and Power Structures – The film explores how belief systems can be manipulated to strip people of agency, turning faith into a psychological prison.
- The Illusion of Free Will – The characters think they have options, but every decision leads them deeper into Mr. Reed’s control.
- Faith vs. Reason – While Sister Barnes begins to see through the illusion, Sister Paxton’s unwavering faith makes her a more susceptible victim.
Acting and Cinematography
Hugh Grant’s Career-Defining Transformation
Hugh Grant delivers one of his best performances to date, completely shedding his charming rom-com persona for something much darker and more cerebral.
- His sinister charisma makes him both terrifying and mesmerizing—his words are calm, almost comforting, yet laced with underlying menace.
- He plays mind games with ease, turning simple theological discussions into psychological warfare.
Sophie Thatcher & Chloe East – The Perfect Foils
- Sophie Thatcher brings a layered, skeptical intelligence to Sister Barnes, making her a grounded counterforce to Mr. Reed’s manipulations.
- Chloe East captures the innocence and blind faith of Sister Paxton, making her descent into psychological torment even more tragic.
Claustrophobic Cinematography & Symbolism
- Shot by Chung Chung-hoon (Oldboy, It), the film uses long, unbroken takes to heighten tension, making scenes feel uncomfortably real.
- Mr. Reed’s house is a puzzle in itself, filled with religious artifacts, cryptic messages, and hidden passageways that mirror the mental maze the characters are trapped in.
- Lighting shifts subtly—what starts as warm and inviting turns cold and oppressive, reflecting the characters’ descent into manipulation and despair.
Directing Style, Strengths, and Weaknesses
Strengths:
- Tension Built Through Dialogue – Heretic proves that horror doesn’t need cheap scares; it can be just as terrifying through psychological manipulation.
- Masterful Performance by Hugh Grant – His calculated, sinister charm carries the entire film.
- Social and Religious Relevance – The film raises uncomfortable but important questions about how belief systems shape our reality.
- Minimalist Horror Done Right – No unnecessary gore, no supernatural gimmicks—just pure, slow-burning terror.
Weaknesses:
- Slow Burn May Not Be for Everyone – Some audiences may find its deliberate pacing frustrating, especially in the first act.
- Limited Rewatch Value – Once the puzzle is solved, the film loses some of its mystery on repeat viewings.
- Ambiguous Ending – Some may appreciate the open-ended nature, but others might find it unsatisfying.
In Conclusion – Is Heretic (2024) Worth Watching?
Absolutely—Heretic is a gripping psychological horror film that deconstructs faith, belief, and power with an unrelenting sense of dread. It’s not just about scaring you—it’s about making you question what you believe and why.
Who Will Love This Movie?
- Fans of psychological horror and slow-burn thrillers (The Witch, The Killing of a Sacred Deer).
- Viewers who enjoy intelligent horror that challenges belief systems (Saint Maud, The Invitation).
- Audiences who appreciate Hugh Grant taking on darker, more complex roles.
Who Might Be Disappointed?
- Viewers expecting traditional horror scares or supernatural elements.
- Audiences who prefer fast-paced storytelling over slow, dialogue-driven tension.
- Those uncomfortable with religious deconstruction themes.
Final Verdict & Score (1–10)
With powerful performances, gripping intellectual horror, and masterful tension, Heretic (2024) stands out as one of A24’s most thought-provoking horror films in recent years. However, its slow pacing and ambiguous nature may not appeal to all audiences.
Final Score: 8/10 – A deeply unsettling psychological horror film that leaves you questioning faith, free will, and the power of belief.
Sources Used to Shape This Review
Insights in this review are drawn from director interviews, fan commentary, production notes, and long-form breakdowns across genre-specific platforms. Content is written uniquely and reviewed for accuracy.
- Heretic Rating Scores
- Our Score: 8/10
- Overall Score: 8.07/10
- MetaCritic: 7.1/10
- Rotten Tomatoes: 9.1/10
Look here for more movies starting with H and here you can find 2024 movies to watch on your favorite streaming service.
Browse Horror Movies 2018 / New Horror Movies